Reverse Mortgage in St Augustine, FL

← Reverse mortgages in Florida

Can you get a reverse mortgage in St Augustine if you still owe on your home? Yes, and it is common. The reverse mortgage pays off your existing loan first, which ends that monthly payment, and whatever equity is left over becomes available to you. On a typical $440K St Augustine home in St. Johns County, a longtime owner often has plenty of equity to cover the payoff and still free up cash.

A typical St. Augustine home is worth around $440K, and for a longtime owner most of that is equity that has sat untouched while Florida values climbed. A reverse mortgage only fits some situations, and I will say so when it does not. See how St. Augustine compares on my Florida aging-in-place overview.

Reverse Mortgage Specialist in St Augustine, FL

Who is a local reverse mortgage broker in St Augustine, FL? Christopher Gibson (NMLS #1910430) is an independent broker with C2 Financial Corporation (NMLS #135622). He helps St Augustine homeowners age 55 and older (age 62+ for the government-insured HECM) turn home equity into funds for retirement. Because the funds are loan proceeds rather than income, they are generally not subject to federal income tax.* Call or text 720-449-6622.

St. Augustine has long drawn retirees to its historic streets and Atlantic beaches, and many residents 62 and older have owned their homes here for decades. With St. Johns County among Florida’s fastest-appreciating markets, those longtime owners are sitting on substantial equity even after a slight cooling this year. That built-up value gives seniors real options for aging comfortably in the place they love.

St. Augustine reverse mortgage facts and figures

St. Augustine draws retirees to the Gulf and Atlantic coasts, and it is the built-up equity in those homes that a reverse mortgage puts to work. Here are a few numbers worth knowing:

Home values: Zillow, mid-2026. HECM limit: HUD/FHA 2026. Property tax: U.S. Census. Figures change, so ask me for today’s numbers on your home.

What is your St. Augustine home worth today?

Curious what your home could be worth, and how much equity you have to work with? Use my free home-value tool below. Enter your address for an instant St. Augustine estimate you can track over time, at no cost and no obligation.

Aging in place in St. Augustine with a reverse mortgage: what it really costs

If your St. Augustine house is fifty years old or more, and you want to replace the windows on the street-facing side, the city classifies that as a partial demolition. Not a repair. That single definition shapes almost everything about how a reverse mortgage should be structured here, and it applies to roughly half the housing stock in the city.

Half this city was built before 1980, and a quarter of it before 1940

The gap between the city and the county is the thing to understand first. St. Augustine’s median home was built in 1980 and 49.7% of its housing predates 1980, with a full 25% standing since before 1940. St. Johns County as a whole has a median build year of 2004 and only 13.9% pre-1980. Same tax roll, two completely different repair conversations.

The city also skews older by population, 27.4% over 65 against 21.1% countywide, while its median home value and median tax bill both come in below the county’s. And here the usual pattern inverts: St. Augustine owners without a mortgage pay more property tax than owners with one, $3,218 against $2,638. That is long-tenured owners sitting on higher-value historic core parcels. It is exactly the profile a reverse mortgage is built for, and exactly the profile most exposed to the preservation rules below.

On a house 50 years or older, replacing visible windows is legally a demolition

This is the most useful thing anyone can tell you about owning an older home here. The city code defines a historic structure as one that is fifty years old or older, or in a historic district, or listed, or contributing. That is a citywide test, not a district test. It then defines partial demolition to include removing historic elements of the building envelope, and this is the operative sentence: the removal of those features counts “regardless of the percentage of the appraised value when they are on visible sides of the building.” Roof, walls, porches, windows, foundations.

Put those two definitions together and a reroof or a window replacement on the street elevation of a fifty-year-old St. Augustine house requires a Certificate of Demolition from the Historic Architectural Review Board: a sign posted seven days out, mailed notice to neighbors within 150 feet, a public hearing, a written order, and a thirty-day appeal window. There is even a required Window Assessment Form that makes you number and photograph every window opening on the house, including the ones you are not touching. The city states plainly that “broken glass or windows that are painted shut are not necessarily grounds for approving replacement.”

What that does to a repair set-aside, and how to plan around it

When a reverse mortgage closes with a repair set-aside, the repairs run on HUD’s clock. The review board here meets once a month, at 1 p.m. on the third Thursday, and applications are due about four weeks before the meeting. Add the thirty-day appeal window and a single clean cycle is roughly two months. Assume two cycles if the first application is incomplete or gets continued, and understand that a contested demolition can be postponed for up to twenty-four months.

The relief valve is that staff, not the board, can sign off on a defined list: repainting the same color from the city’s pre-approved palette, structural maintenance and repair using the same materials and architectural character, work that is not visible, and air conditioning equipment. So like-for-like repair moves fast and anything new or visible does not. Get the scope in front of the planning department before we set the set-aside amount and the deadline, not after.

One offsetting piece of good news that almost nobody claims: both the city and the county grant an ad valorem tax exemption on 100% of the assessed value of qualifying historic improvements for ten years. If you are being forced into a compliant restoration anyway, that exemption is worth asking about in the same meeting.

Coquina needs lime mortar, and that changes a repair bid

The historic masonry here is coquina, the shell limestone quarried on Anastasia Island that built the Castillo de San Marcos starting in 1672. It is porous and soft, and it has to be repointed with lime-based mortar. A contractor who repoints coquina or tabby with modern Portland cement will spall the stone and fail review. Any mason who has worked in this town for twenty years knows that. A low bid from someone who does not is the most expensive quote you will get, and it is worth catching before the money is drawn.

Flooding, and a rating that just improved

FEMA notified the city in August 2025 that St. Augustine moves up to Community Rating System Class 4, a 30% flood insurance discount on most policies issued or renewed on or after April 1, 2026, up from Class 5 and 25%. That is a genuine and unusual achievement, and the city needs it: 4,563 buildings sit in the special flood hazard area, and the city carries FEMA’s repetitive-loss Category C, meaning fifty or more repetitive-loss properties. The city itself says about 90% of residents live in a floodplain, which is its own characterization and broader than the mapped high-risk zone.

The two storms people still measure by: Matthew in October 2016 put water up to four feet above ground level in the city, especially near the bayfront and the San Sebastian River, and Irma in September 2017 flooded many of the same streets, with surveyed high water two to four feet above ground and an EF-1 tornado in town. The city is now building the $30 million Lake Maria Sanchez flood mitigation project, a pump station, flood wall and tide check valves protecting roughly 200 acres of the historic district. Countywide, 23.2% of residential structures carry flood insurance.

Four FHA-approved condominium projects in the whole county

When I searched HUD’s approved condominium database for St. Johns County on August 15, 2026, four projects came back approved, and only two of those are in St. Augustine: Vista Cove and The Lofts at Sebastian Cove. The rest of the county’s fifty-odd project records are expired, rejected or withdrawn, including one flagged ineligible because of short-term rentals. One of the four approvals expires in September 2026.

Set that against 28.6% of city housing sitting in buildings of five or more units. A standard HECM wants the whole project FHA-approved. Where it is not, Single-Unit Approval is the path, and for a reverse mortgage it carries a stricter residual income standard. Check your building first, and check it again if you are reading this months from now.

The senior exemption, and the number I am not going to print

The City of St. Augustine adopted an additional senior exemption in 2006, and the ordinance reads “twenty-five thousand dollars, or up to fifty thousand dollars when and if permitted by law.” The Legislature raised that cap to $50,000 back in 2007, so the city very likely grants the full amount today, which at its 7.5000 mills would be worth $375 a year rather than $187.50. Very likely is not good enough to put in writing, and I could not locate the county’s ordinance at all, because St. Johns County does not publish a searchable code. Ask the Property Appraiser for both figures before you budget.

What I can tell you flatly is that a reverse mortgage does not touch either one. Florida law makes a mortgage a lien rather than a transfer of title, so your homestead exemption, your Save Our Homes cap and your senior exemption all survive the closing. Ownership stays with you, and so does the duty to pay the taxes, carry the insurance and maintain the house.

St. Johns County Property Appraiser, exemptions

No trauma center in the county, and the most walkable core in Florida

St. Johns County has no state-designated trauma center at any level. UF Health Flagler Hospital here in town is a 335-bed full-service acute care hospital, renamed when UF Health completed the acquisition in September 2023, but it is not a trauma center. The nearest Level I is UF Health Jacksonville, roughly forty-five miles up I-95.

The compensation is that this is the one Florida market where you can genuinely age out of a car. Walk Score does not publish a citywide number for St. Augustine, but St. George Street and King Street both score 90 out of 100, a Walker’s Paradise, which is close to unheard of in this state. The Sunshine Bus Company is run by the county Council on Aging, a genuinely unusual arrangement, at $2.00 a ride or $1.00 for riders 60 and older and Medicare cardholders, with a $15 monthly pass at the discounted rate. They also run door-to-door paratransit for transportation-disadvantaged and 60+ residents.

And Florida takes nothing off the top

The oldest continuously occupied European-established settlement in the continental United States also happens to sit in a state with no income tax and no estate or inheritance tax. For a family holding a house that has been in it for decades, that second part matters: what your heirs inherit is the home and whatever equity sits above the loan balance, with no state bill attached. Reverse mortgage proceeds are loan advances rather than income, so they are not taxed and they do not count toward the $38,686 senior exemption income limit.

The measures that decide whether staying works

On the government’s own price parity index, where the US averages 100, the Jacksonville, FL metro area sits at 99. County life expectancy runs 81.0 years, comfortably past the 77.1 national mark. The growing line of credit rewards exactly one thing, and that thing is time. On the weather, snow is essentially a non-issue, and 55 days a year top 90F, on 252 dry days a year. The number that matters most is the last one. Holding a mortgage-free home here runs $793 a month, 16% of what a typical 65+ household takes in.

Sources: U.S. Census ACS 2020-2024 5-Year (B01001, B25003, B25024, B25034, B25035, B25077, B25103), St. Augustine city and St. Johns County; City of St. Augustine Code §2-190 (Ord. 06-39), Ch. 28 Art. III Div. 4 (§§28-181 to 28-190), §§28-2, 28-84 to 28-92, 28-89 and 28-90, and the Architectural Guidelines for Historic Preservation; City of St. Augustine Window Condition Assessment Survey Form and pre-approved color palette; City Code Ch. 2 Art. VII and St. Johns County Ord. 2022-55 (Fla. Stat. §196.1997 historic improvement exemption); St. Johns County Property Appraiser and Florida Dept. of Revenue Table 1 comparison of taxes levied; Florida Dept. of Revenue additional homestead exemption bulletin, January 2026; Fla. Stat. §§196.075, 193.155, 697.02; FEMA CRS cycle verification letter to the City of St. Augustine, August 13, 2025; FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP residential penetration rates, August 3, 2026; Citizens Property Insurance policies in force, July 31, 2026; NHC Tropical Cyclone Reports AL142016 (Matthew) and AL112017 (Irma); City of St. Augustine Lake Maria Sanchez project fact sheet; HUD FHA condominium database, searched August 15, 2026; Florida Dept. of Health verified trauma center list, July 23, 2026; UF Health; National Park Service on coquina and the Castillo de San Marcos; Sunshine Bus Company and St. Johns County Council on Aging; Walk Score (address-level, no citywide score is published). No official St. Augustine dollar damage figure exists for Matthew or Irma, so none is given. Figures are educational, verify your own before relying on them.

Quick guide: is a reverse mortgage right for me?

First, answer four short questions, and the guide will point you toward the resource that fits your situation. Of course, it is general guidance for learning, not an approval or a quote, and nothing you tap is stored.

Learn how reverse mortgages work

Reverse mortgage options in St. Augustine: HECM vs. jumbo

Most homes here are covered by the government-insured HECM, while higher-value homes and many condos fit a proprietary jumbo. For the full side-by-side of HECM, jumbo, HELOC, and HEI, see the reverse mortgage comparison table, or the types of reverse mortgages for a plain-English rundown.

For a full side-by-side of every program and how to choose, see the types of reverse mortgages.

Buying a home? Consider a HECM for Purchase (H4P)

A HECM for Purchase lets you buy your next home using a reverse mortgage, so you put down a portion and finance the rest with no required monthly principal-and-interest payment. For a St. Augustine owner leaving a two-story house for a single-level villa or a low-maintenance condo, it is a clean way to move without taking on a new monthly payment.

How much you can access depends on age, rates, and value. Start your own estimate with the reverse mortgage calculator below.

Full detail, including what you would need to bring at each age, is on the HECM for Purchase page.

How the process works, step by step

Consultation, HUD counseling, application, appraisal, closing, with a three-day right to cancel. Most St. Johns County files fund in 30 to 45 days. Here is how a reverse mortgage works, step by step.

How much a reverse mortgage costs in St Augustine

The biggest cost is FHA mortgage insurance: 2% of the home’s value upfront, plus about 0.5% a year on the balance, and that upfront premium funds the FHA guarantee behind the non-recourse protection. On a typical St. Augustine home at $440K that is about $8,800 at closing, and most of it rolls into the loan. Every fee, itemized.

The honest trade-offs (the balance grows, you still cover taxes and insurance, and it rewards a longer stay) are the same anywhere. I lay them all out in the pros and cons of a reverse mortgage.

Why work with a mortgage broker, not a bank

A bank sells you one rate sheet. I shop the same loan across more than 30 wholesale lenders, which also opens up the proprietary and jumbo programs a single bank cannot offer, and at St. Augustine’s $440K median that is often the difference between a HECM and a materially bigger draw. C2 Financial Corporation, NMLS #135622.

What happens to your home and your heirs

You keep the title, and the loan is non-recourse, so you and your heirs can never owe more than the home is worth. Heirs can repay, refinance, or sell and keep the rest, and Florida has no estate or inheritance tax to complicate it. Timelines and the 95% rule.

What about condos and HOA approval?

A HECM needs the whole project FHA-approved and plenty of St. Augustine buildings are not. That matters a great deal here: when I searched HUD's approved list on August 15, 2026, only four condominium projects in all of St. Johns County came back approved, and just two of those are in St. Augustine. A proprietary loan can often finance one that is not, so check the building before you assume the answer is no. Start with my HOA checklist. Property and eligibility rules.

The HUD counseling requirement, explained

Federal HUD rules require an independent HUD-approved session before closing, usually low-cost or free, and it has to be finished before I can pull an FHA case number. HUD publishes the approved counselors serving St. Johns County, so scheduling never has to stall your file. Find counselors through HUD’s HECM program. Florida Office of Financial Regulation publishes consumer guidance. What the session actually covers.

Reverse mortgage FAQs for St. Augustine homeowners

Can you get a reverse mortgage in St Augustine if you still have a mortgage?

Yes, and it is common. The reverse mortgage pays off your existing mortgage first, which ends that monthly payment, and whatever equity remains becomes available to you. You just need enough equity to cover the payoff. Here is how qualifying with an existing mortgage works.

Can I get a reverse mortgage on a St. Augustine condo?

Often, yes. A standard FHA HECM needs the whole condo project to be FHA-approved, and many buildings are not. When that is the case, a proprietary reverse mortgage can usually finance a non-approved or non-warrantable condo. I check your specific building first.

How much can I borrow in St. Augustine?

It depends on the youngest borrower's age, current rates, and your home value. Most St. Augustine homes fall within the standard FHA HECM limit, while higher-value homes may also fit a jumbo program that exceeds it.

Is HUD counseling required in St Augustine?

Yes. You must complete a session with a HUD-approved counselor before closing. It is usually low-cost or free. HUD publishes the approved counselors serving St. Johns County, so scheduling never has to slow you down.

Do I still pay property tax with a reverse mortgage in St. Augustine?

Yes. With a reverse mortgage you keep title and remain responsible for property taxes, homeowners insurance, and upkeep. Depending on your age and income you may qualify for senior property-tax relief in Florida (the programs vary by state and by county), and you can use reverse-mortgage funds to help cover those ongoing costs.

Have a question about a reverse mortgage in St. Augustine? Call or text me at 720-449-6622. No pressure, just straight answers.

St. Augustine neighborhoods and nearby areas I serve

I work with homeowners across the city and greater St. Johns County. That includes Lincolnville, Davis Shores, Anastasia Island, World Golf Village, North City, and Fullerwood Park. Core ZIP codes include 32080, 32084, 32085, 32086, 32092, 32095.

In addition, I also help owners in nearby communities such as Palm Coast, St. Augustine Beach, Ponte Vedra, Vilano Beach, Fernandina Beach, and World Golf Village, and across St. Johns, and Flagler counties. See every area I cover on my reverse mortgages across Florida page. Do not see your area? Reach out and ask.

If aging in place is your goal, local resources like ElderSource, Northeast Florida Area Agency on Aging, and St. Johns County Council on Aging can help you plan, and my free Aging-in-Place Home Scorecard lets you score any St. Augustine home in about 15 minutes to see how ready it is to grow old in.

About Christopher Gibson

Christopher Gibson (NMLS #1910430) is an independent mortgage and reverse mortgage broker with C2 Financial Corporation (NMLS #135622), serving homeowners across the states he is licensed in. Serving St. Augustine and nearby communities. Call or text 720-449-6622. More about Christopher.

Read reviews of Reverse Mortgages & Home Loans with Christopher Gibson at C2 Financial

Google Business Profile →  ·  Mortgage Matchup →

*This is general information, not tax advice. Reverse mortgage proceeds are loan advances rather than income and are generally not subject to federal income tax. Consult a CPA or tax advisor about your specific situation. Receiving loan proceeds may also affect eligibility for need-based government benefits such as Medicaid or Supplemental Security Income (SSI).